When an illness strikes Katherine Yoder with amnesia, she cannot recall her past relationships with two suitors--childhood friend Johnny, and Isaac, who claims they discussed marriage through a series of love letters.
Laura Stutzman leaves her Kentucky community for Middlefield, Ohio, with one purpose: to find Mark King, the man who pledged his love to her, then left, so that she can move on with her life.
Raising her siblings after their parents' deaths, Emma has always put their needs above her own, but when her first love, Adam, returns to the community of Middlefield, he tries to convince her to make decisions for herself.